Monday, September 13, 2010

The Peanut Butter Chick Magnet Cookie

This is a BLOW YOUR SOCKS OFF COOKIE! About eight years ago, I started a cookie business: THE COOKIE CHICKS. We named all our cookies "something" chick. We had one called The Chick Magnet. It was the favorite. I recently came up with this new one that I now call the ''Peanut Butter Chick Magnet''. It's like eating a candy bar. In the middle of a moist peanut butter cookie is a peanut butter cup. It is dipped in chocolate, doused with chopped PB cups and mini chocolate chips, then drizzled with white chocolate. AMAZING. You will think you have died and gone to heaven. It is a beautiful cookie! ENJOY!

1/2 cup Crisco
3/4 cup peanut butter
3/4 cups brown sugar
3/4 cups white sugar
1 egg
3/4 tsp salt
3/4 tsp baking soda
1 1/2 cup flour
3 T milk
1 tsp vanilla
miniature peanut butter cups
mini chocolate chips
white chocolate

Mix all but the last three ingredients together. Unwrap about 4 dozen mini peanut butter cups. Scoop about 2 T of dough, flatten, and place a PB cup in the center. Wrap dough around and shape into a ball. Place on cookie sheet. Bake at 350 for 8-10 minutes. Cool. Melt dipping chocolate. (I use Trader Joe's Milk Chocolate. It is the best!) Dip tops of cookies in chocolate and lay on wax paper. Chop up remaining PB cups. Sprinkle tops of cookies with the cups and mini chocolate chips. Allow to set. Drizzle with white chocolate. YUM!


  1. Is it possible to drool so much over a cookie? I think I have!!! Stephanie, those cookies are amazing! Between this post and Sarah's cracker tofee, I better start doubling my workouts...they are worth it!

  2. Well, I linked your blog to my newlywed daughters fb page... I think she will love all of the fun stuff you all make.


  3. This one sounds fabulous. I don't generally make cookies- too fussy. But I have GOT to try this one! Thanks.

  4. This is much more than a cookie. It is truly a sinful indulgence. BEWARE. Consider yourselves warned!

  5. I didn't know you had a blog...or three?! I LOVE anything PB and chocolate and these look so amazing. I will be trying these ASAP! Thanks for sharing, Steph!

  6. I tried these and they didn't turn out. Is there something missing? It seems like the dough is missing sugar. It was quite crumbly. The cookie ended up in a big ball rather than a nice flat cookie. Any advice?

  7. Hot Hades!!! I forgot to list the sugar!! If your dough turns out crumbly, add a little milk, like 1 Tb. at a time until it is soft enough. Soooo sorry!!!!!